TY - JOUR
T1 - Petrogenesis of magmatic albite granites associated to cogenetic A-type granites
T2 - Na-rich residual melt extraction from a partially crystallized A-type granite mush
AU - Barboni, Mélanie
AU - Bussy, François
N1 - Funding Information:
We thank Alexey Ulianov (University of Lausanne, Switzerland) for his input in the LA-ICP-MS data acquisition, Massimo Chiaradia (University of Geneva, Switzerland) for his help in the Sr–Nd–Pb isotope acquisition and Axel Gerdes (University of Frankfurt-am-Main, Germany) for the Hf in zircon isotope determination. We also thank Jean-Claude Lavanchy and Laurent Nicod (University of Lausanne, Switzerland) for their technical support in sample preparation and XRF data acquisition. We express our deepest gratitude to Prof. Boris Litvinovski (University of the Negev) for his eye-opening review and for suggesting to us the very convincing model of residual melt extraction. We also thank Prof. Nelson Eby, Editor-in-chief, for his pertinent comments. This ongoing study was funded by the Swiss National Science Foundation , grant 200021-116705 and by the «Société Académique Vaudoise» in Lausanne .
PY - 2013/9/1
Y1 - 2013/9/1
N2 - The uncommon association of cogenetic and nearly contemporaneous potassic K-feldspar A-type granites and sodic albite granites is observed within the 347Ma-old bimodal Saint-Jean-du-Doigt (SJDD) intrusion, Brittany, France. A-type granites outcrop as small bodies (<1km2) of fine-grained, pinkish to yellowish rock or as meter-thick sills in-between mafic layers. They emplaced early within the thermally "cool" part of the SJDD pluton directly beneath the Precambrian host rock, forming the pluton roof. Albite granites are fine-grained hololeucocratic yellowish rocks emplaced slightly after the A-type granites in the thermally mature part of the pluton. They form meter-thick sills that mingle with adjacent mafic layers and represent ca. 1vol.% of the outcropping part of the pluton.The two granite types are similar in many respects with comparable Sr-Nd-Hf isotope compositions (87Sr/86Sr347=0.7071 for A-type granites vs. 0.7073 for albite granites; εNd347=+0.2 vs. +0.3; εHf347zircon=+2.47 vs. +2.71, respectively) and SiO2 contents (74.8 vs. 74.4wt.%). On the other hand, they have contrasting concentrations in K2O (5.30 vs. 1.97wt.%), Na2O (2.95 vs. 4.73wt.%) and CaO (0.48 vs. 2.04, respectively) as well as in some trace elements like Sr (59 vs. 158ppm in average), Rb (87 vs. 35ppm), Cr (170 vs. 35ppm) and Ga (30 vs. 20ppm). The isotopic composition of the A-type and albite granites is very distinct from that of the associated and volumetrically dominant mafic rocks (i.e. 87Sr/86Sr347=0.7042; εNd347=+5.07; εHf347zircon=+8.11), excluding a direct derivation of the felsic rocks through fractional crystallization from the basaltic magma. On the other hand, small volumes of hybrid, enclave-bearing granodiorite within the SJDD lopolith suggest mixing processes within a reservoir located at deeper crustal levels. A-type granites may therefore form by magma mixing between the mafic magma and crustal melts. Alternatively, they might derive from the pure melting of an immature biotite-bearing quartz-feldspathic crustal protolith induced by early mafic injections at low crustal levels.Strong field evidences coupled to mineral chemistry and elemental geochemistry strongly support a magmatic origin for the albite granite. Sr, Nd, Hf zircon isotope data, U-Pb zircon ages, as well as data on petrography, mineral chemistry and elemental geochemistry attest that A-type and albite granites are closely related. Our preferred petrogenetic model is to consider the albite granite magma as a compositionally extreme melt that was extracted from a partially crystallized A-type granite mush at a late stage of crystallization. Alternatively, albite granites could form by melting of plagioclase-rich layers formed during A-type granite differentiation.
AB - The uncommon association of cogenetic and nearly contemporaneous potassic K-feldspar A-type granites and sodic albite granites is observed within the 347Ma-old bimodal Saint-Jean-du-Doigt (SJDD) intrusion, Brittany, France. A-type granites outcrop as small bodies (<1km2) of fine-grained, pinkish to yellowish rock or as meter-thick sills in-between mafic layers. They emplaced early within the thermally "cool" part of the SJDD pluton directly beneath the Precambrian host rock, forming the pluton roof. Albite granites are fine-grained hololeucocratic yellowish rocks emplaced slightly after the A-type granites in the thermally mature part of the pluton. They form meter-thick sills that mingle with adjacent mafic layers and represent ca. 1vol.% of the outcropping part of the pluton.The two granite types are similar in many respects with comparable Sr-Nd-Hf isotope compositions (87Sr/86Sr347=0.7071 for A-type granites vs. 0.7073 for albite granites; εNd347=+0.2 vs. +0.3; εHf347zircon=+2.47 vs. +2.71, respectively) and SiO2 contents (74.8 vs. 74.4wt.%). On the other hand, they have contrasting concentrations in K2O (5.30 vs. 1.97wt.%), Na2O (2.95 vs. 4.73wt.%) and CaO (0.48 vs. 2.04, respectively) as well as in some trace elements like Sr (59 vs. 158ppm in average), Rb (87 vs. 35ppm), Cr (170 vs. 35ppm) and Ga (30 vs. 20ppm). The isotopic composition of the A-type and albite granites is very distinct from that of the associated and volumetrically dominant mafic rocks (i.e. 87Sr/86Sr347=0.7042; εNd347=+5.07; εHf347zircon=+8.11), excluding a direct derivation of the felsic rocks through fractional crystallization from the basaltic magma. On the other hand, small volumes of hybrid, enclave-bearing granodiorite within the SJDD lopolith suggest mixing processes within a reservoir located at deeper crustal levels. A-type granites may therefore form by magma mixing between the mafic magma and crustal melts. Alternatively, they might derive from the pure melting of an immature biotite-bearing quartz-feldspathic crustal protolith induced by early mafic injections at low crustal levels.Strong field evidences coupled to mineral chemistry and elemental geochemistry strongly support a magmatic origin for the albite granite. Sr, Nd, Hf zircon isotope data, U-Pb zircon ages, as well as data on petrography, mineral chemistry and elemental geochemistry attest that A-type and albite granites are closely related. Our preferred petrogenetic model is to consider the albite granite magma as a compositionally extreme melt that was extracted from a partially crystallized A-type granite mush at a late stage of crystallization. Alternatively, albite granites could form by melting of plagioclase-rich layers formed during A-type granite differentiation.
KW - A-type granite
KW - Albite granite
KW - Liquid extraction
KW - Plagioclase remelting
KW - Residual melt
KW - Variscan belt
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84882751264&partnerID=8YFLogxK
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84882751264&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1016/j.lithos.2013.07.005
DO - 10.1016/j.lithos.2013.07.005
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:84882751264
SN - 0024-4937
VL - 177
SP - 328
EP - 351
JO - LITHOS
JF - LITHOS
ER -